Singapore

Why Your Agency Might Not Want You to Understand Attribution

Agency attribution reporting dashboard example

The Hidden World of Attribution in Digital Marketing

Attribution is how marketers track which ad, keyword, or campaign drives a conversion. It answers the big question: Which part of my marketing spend is actually working?

But here’s the catch—many agencies don’t want you to fully understand it. Why? Because once you do, you might see that not every dollar they’re charging you is returning value.

According to HubSpot’s State of Marketing Report 2024, only 35% of businesses feel confident in their marketing ROI tracking. That leaves a big blind spot—and agencies sometimes benefit from keeping that blind spot open.

Why Agencies Keep Attribution Complex

The Incentive Problem

Agencies are often paid on metrics like clicks, impressions, or spend—not necessarily results. If you knew that half of your conversions were actually coming from organic search or word-of-mouth, you might ask, “Why am I spending $10,000 on ads every month?”

The Data Overload Trap

Attribution reports can be overwhelming. Multi-touch, first-click, last-click, data-driven models—it’s alphabet soup for most business owners. Agencies sometimes lean into this complexity, presenting data in ways that confuse instead of clarify.

A 2023 MarketingProfs study found that 62% of SME owners don’t understand attribution models. When you don’t understand, you rely more on your agency—exactly what they want.

What Real Data Shows About Attribution

Let’s look at an example from Singapore’s education sector (a high-CPC industry):

Campaign Performance Table
Campaign Performance Comparison
Campaign Type
Avg. CTR
Avg. CPL
Attribution Model Impact
Generic keywords
Avg. CTR: 1.9%
Avg. CPL: $42
Attribution Model Impact: Over-reports conversions
School-proximity targeting
Avg. CTR: 3.2%
Avg. CPL: $28
Attribution Model Impact: Better reflects local intent
Commuter path targeting
Avg. CTR: 2.7%
Avg. CPL: $31
Attribution Model Impact: Captures mid-funnel users

Here’s the kicker: under a last-click model, generic keywords looked like the hero. But under a data-driven model, school-proximity targeting was the real driver of enrolments. Without proper attribution, the school would have doubled down on the wrong campaign.

Case Study – How Misattribution Costs Businesses

A tuition centre in Singapore worked with an agency that ran both Google Ads and Meta Ads. The agency claimed Meta was generating 70% of the leads. But when the centre brought in an independent audit with Google Analytics 4, they discovered:

• 50% of the leads came from organic search
• 30% from Google Ads (search campaigns)
• Only 20% from Meta Ads

The tuition centre had been overspending on Meta for 8 months. The agency wasn’t lying—but by using a simplistic attribution model, they made Meta look like the hero.

Hero Section - Boost Enrollment

Boost Sales With Thrive's Digital Strategy

Connect with our expert team to transform your sales process with proven digital marketing strategies that deliver real results.

Connect with us!

Why This Trap is Common for SMEs in Singapore (and Southeast Asia)

High CPC Industries

Singapore SMEs in education, finance, and real estate face CPCs as high as $15–$25 per click. With such steep costs, agencies push aggressive ad spend to hit vanity metrics—without always proving ROI.

Cultural Buying Behavior

In Southeast Asia, buyers often research extensively across multiple platforms before committing. That means a parent might click your Google ad, visit your website, see your Facebook post later, then finally enquire via WhatsApp. Without proper attribution, agencies may credit only the final click, ignoring the actual customer journey.

Lack of Local Expertise

Many SMEs rely on regional agencies that use U.S. or Europe-focused benchmarks. But local behavior differs.

For example, Mothership.sg reports that Singaporeans are far more likely to trust peer recommendations and local review sites like The Smart Local before converting. Agencies that ignore these touchpoints under-attribute crucial parts of the journey.

How to Spot If Your Agency is Holding Back Attribution

Red Flags

• You only see last-click reports.
• The agency avoids setting up GA4 or CRM tracking.
• Reports highlight ad spend, not profit or cost-per-enrolment.
• No transparency on cross-channel attribution.

Actionable Advice

• Request data-driven attribution in Google Ads and GA4.
• Cross-check agency reports with independent tools.
• Track conversions tied to real outcomes (enrolments, not just form fills).
• Benchmark against Forbes-reported industry averages for CPL and ROI.

Lets built the
Perfect Sales Funnel Together

Your business deserves more. Let ThriveMediaSG help your business Increase Sales through digital marketing.

Mistakes & Traps – FAQs from Google

Mistakes & Traps – FAQs from Google

Understand hidden risks in attribution and reporting models that may mislead business owners.

Can my agency hide bad performance with attribution?

Yes. By using last-click or first-click attribution models, agencies can over-credit certain campaigns while hiding underperformers.

Should I rely only on agency dashboards?

No. Use GA4, CRM integrations, and independent audits to validate results beyond what the agency dashboard shows you.

Does complex attribution always mean better?

Not always. Simpler, transparent models (like linear or time decay) are often better than overly complex multi-touch setups designed to obscure results.

How do I know if I’m overspending?

Compare your cost-per-enrolment with local benchmarks. In Singapore, tuition centres report CPLs between $25–$40 on Google Ads when optimized properly.

THRIVEMEDIASG_ Digital Marketing Agency

Trusted by leading startups & enterprises

Why Your Business Matter to ThriveMedia?

Our team consists of seasoned digital marketers, bringing years of hands-on expertise driving results for SMEs and enterprises throughout the APAC region.

✓ We Track Every Step

from first click to final sale—across Meta, Google, TikTok, YouTube, and your CRM so you can see what’s working and what’s not.

✓ We handle everything in-house.

Your videos, landing pages, ads, and data are aligned under one strategy no more juggling vendors.

✓ We adapt instantly.

Budgets shift based on real-time performance, not monthly meetings.

✓ We make your existing data work harder.

Leads and traffic you already have get optimized for higher ROI and less waste.

✓ We keep it real.

Clear reports, honest feedback, and no jargon—even when results aren’t perfect.

Digital Marketing isn’t just about running ads—it’s about turning data into visible growth.

lets built the funnel together

Provide us with your best contact details - We're sure to drop you a personalised message.